Many founders spend weeks negotiating valuation, shareholding percentages and investment terms, but the single document most likely to determine the future of their business relationship might actually be the humble shareholders' agreement.
When co-founders/shareholders are aligned and the business is growing, it is easy to assume that disputes will never arise. Unfortunately, disagreements about control, profit-sharing, exits and strategy are often inevitable.
A well-drafted shareholders' agreement helps address these issues before they become disputes.
Here are 10 clauses every founder should understand.
1. Ownership Structure
Every shareholders' agreement should clearly state:
Who owns what percentage of the company;
The number of shares held;
The classes of shares issued; and
Any special rights attached to those shares.
Many conflicts start because founders assume everyone has the same understanding of ownership arrangements when they do not.
2. Board Composition
Ownership and control are not always the same thing. A founder who owns less shares may still exert significant influence through board representation.
The agreement should address:
How directors are appointed;
Removal rights;
Board voting procedures;
Reserved board seats.
3. Reserved Matters
Certain decisions are too important or too large to be made by a simple majority.
Examples may include:
Issuing new shares;
Raising funding;
Selling substantial assets;
Entering major transactions;
Winding up the business.
Reserved matters clauses identify decisions requiring enhanced approval thresholds.
4. Pre-Emption Rights
Pre-emption rights protect shareholders against unwanted dilution. When new shares are issued, existing shareholders are given the opportunity to participate before the shares are offered to outsiders. This protection is particularly important for minority shareholders.
5. Restrictions on Share Transfers
Founders often assume they can choose their business partners.
However, without proper restrictions, a shareholder may potentially transfer shares to a third party that the remaining shareholders do not wish to work with. Transfer restriction clauses commonly include rights of first refusal and approval requirements.
6. Tag-Along Rights
Tag-along rights protect minority shareholders.
If a majority shareholder sells his or her stake, a tag-along clause allows minority shareholders to participate in the sale on the same terms. Without such protection, minority shareholders may find themselves locked into a company controlled by an entirely different owner.
7. Drag-Along Rights
The opposite issue may also arise. A potential buyer may wish to acquire the entire company but be unable to do so because a minority shareholder refuses to sell.
Drag-along rights allow qualifying majority shareholders to require minority shareholders to participate in a sale on the same terms.
8. Founder Exit and Good Leaver/Bad Leaver Provisions
Not every founder stays forever, and not every founder leaves on good terms.
Questions that should be addressed include:
What if a founder resigns?
What if a founder is terminated?
What if a founder becomes incapacitated?
Must departing founders sell their shares?
Good leaver and bad leaver provisions often determine how departing founders' shares will be treated.
9. Deadlock Resolution
Deadlock can occur when key decision-makers fundamentally disagree. This is particularly problematic in businesses with:
Two founders;
Equal shareholdings;
Equal board control.
The agreement should establish a mechanism for resolving deadlocks before they threaten the viability of the business.
Possible solutions include:
Escalation procedures;
Mediation;
Buy-out mechanisms;
Shotgun clauses.
10. Dispute Resolution
While one expects to sue their co-founder when the company is incorporated, but many shareholder disputes eventually arise because there is no agreed process for resolving disagreements.
The agreement should clearly specify:
Governing law;
Jurisdiction;
Mediation requirements;
Arbitration provisions where appropriate.
Conclusion
A shareholders' agreement is not merely a corporate formality. It is often the most important risk-management document a private company can have.
For founders, investors and business owners, a well-drafted agreement can provide certainty, protect investments and significantly reduce the likelihood of costly disputes as the company grows.
If you require advice on drafting, reviewing or enforcing a shareholders' agreement, the team at Linea Law LLC may be able to assist.